Emily meets Sam at Sloan alternative school. Rebellion against authority expels both from public school setting. Emily is determined to live her life HER way sans interference from adults especially any guidance from God! Sam's problem; school is a bore! Perpetual absenteeism, his escape.
Emily discovers life without adult supervision dangerous. Under attack in the classroom, her money stolen, assignments destroyed etc., she yearns for adult protection. Emily meets Sam, is unimpressed. Later, he becomes her crutch; she can depend on him to maintain her sanity. With changed attitudes and resolution to finish their course, Emily and Sam emerge stronger and more focused re their future.
At a church sponsored New Year's party they meet. A Happy New Year's kiss sends Sam into orbit. He's in love; declares his love for Emily. Returning to Yale determined to call Emily, forgets his promise. They meet again at the next New Year's party. Sam watches as another guy kisses Emily. Distraught, Sam has his work cut out if he's to win back his Emily.